Who dunnit?

A gramme is better than a damn! Pull up a chair, have a drink, and banter.

Moderator: Thought Police

Vague One
Posts: 918
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2004 9:44 am
Location: A top a wet and windy moor

Who dunnit?

Post by Vague One »

Willo emailed me this because she was trying to work out the correct answer. I don't have the solution so I want to see if other people get the same answer.
Four suspects - Jack Vicious, Sid Shifty, Alf Muggins and Jim Pouncer are being interviewed at the scene of a murder. Each suspect is asked a question and their answers are below:

Jack Vicious: "Sid Shifty committed the murder"
Sid Shifty: "Jim Pouncer committed the murder"
Alf Muggins: "I didn't commit the murder"
Jim Pouncer: "Sid Shifty is lying"

Only one of the four answers is the truth, which is it and who committed the murder?
Cheers for your help people.